RESULT: Police and Crime Commissioner
| Name of Candidate | Description | Votes |
| ALLEN David Stewart | English Democrats –“More Police – catching criminals!” | 19,144 |
| BILLINGS Alan Roy | Labour Party | 144,978 |
| FELTON Gavin Patrick | UK Independence Party (UKIP) | 57,062 |
| OTTEN Joe | Liberal Democrats | 28,060 |
| WALKER Ian Geoffrey | The Conservative Party Candidate | 29,904 |
- The turnout in the South Yorkshire Police Area at this election was 29.48%
- At the by-election in 2014 it was: 14.88%.
- At the election of the first ever PCC in 2012 it was: 14.93%.